Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mike Perceval's avatar

Thank you a very informative and interesting article, Ben. You write:

“Cyrus was not uniquely pro-Jewish, but rather had a general policy of supporting the repatriation of exiles and rebuilding of temples. As the ruler of a multi-ethnic, multi-religious empire, his “universal Zionism” was undoubtedly self-interested, as it encouraged subject peoples to accept Persian rule.”

And you go on to elaborate upon Cyrus being viewed by many as ‘a model King’.

I agree on both accounts; that he was acting out of self-interest and a model King. And he may indeed not have been ‘uniquely pro-Jewish’.

But, I would suggest that, along with Nebuchadnezzar, at a given point, Cyrus received a sufficient realization of reality to at least become ‘pro-Yahweh’, and act appropriately on that realization.

This highlights an intriguing historical, phenomenon; the fact that so many people have had, or have, enough familiarity with the Bible to know what Genesis 12:3 says, but fail to believe 1) that the Bible really is what it purports to be; the Word of G-d Almighty, or 2) that it really means what it says, here and elsewhere.

Oh, there is so much that could be shared off this spring of Truth. But I will close with this other excerpt from that same Word of the Living G-d:

Psalms 2 (Tanakh)

1 Why do nations assemble, and peoples plot vain things; 2 kings of the earth take their stand, and regents intrigue together against the LORD and against His anointed? 3 “Let us break the cords of their yoke, shake off their ropes from us!"

4 He who is enthroned in heaven laughs; the Lord mocks at them.

5 Then He speaks to them in anger, terrifying them in His rage, 6 “But I have installed My king on Zion, My holy mountain!"

7 Let me tell of the decree:

the LORD said to me, “You are My son, I have fathered you this day. 8 Ask it of Me, and I will make the nations your domain; your estate, the limits of the earth. 9 You can smash them with an iron mace, shatter them like potter’s ware.”

10 So now, O kings, be prudent;

accept discipline, you rulers of the earth!

11 Serve the LORD in awe;

tremble with fright, 12 pay homage in good faith, lest He be angered, and your way be doomed in the mere flash of His anger.

Happy are all who take refuge in Him.

Am Israel Chai!

Expand full comment

No posts